Hello FAC Community,
It has been shown that, in the fire-adapted Southwest, forest restoration and fuel reduction treatments are the primary and most effective means of reestablishing beneficial fire regimes and protecting communities and ecosystems from devastating wildfire. However, these treatments need to happen at large scale, in the right places, and for the right price. Today’s newsletter explores two aspects of this challenge - how cost-effective forest and fuels treatments really are, and how planning and implementing them can be most efficacious when done collaboratively.
This Wildfire Wednesday features:
Meta-analysis of the impact of forest treatments (thinning and prescribed burning)
Funding opportunities
In-person learning (Taos, Fire Preparedness)
Upcoming webinars
Best wishes,
Rachel
Forest Treatments Meta-analysis
In August 2024, Northern Arizona University's Ecological Restoration Institute conducted and published a meta-analysis of the cost benefits of fuel treatments including thinning and prescribed burns. This analysis evaluates and compiles the findings of the many studies which have been published on this topic in the past.
Forest restoration and fuel treatments, including thinning and prescribed burning, have become the primary approaches for reducing the abundance of overly dense stands and reestablishing natural fire regimes. Although there is a strong body of biophysical science supporting these approaches, little is known about their cost effectiveness. To evaluate forest restoration and fuel treatment benefits and costs, a team of researchers at the ERI and the Conservation Economics Institute conducted a meta-analysis of benefit-cost ratios for restoration benefit types documented in the literature for western US dry mixed-conifer forests at risk of uncharacteristic wildfires.
The analysis is the first quantitative synthesis of the return on investments in forest restoration for the American West. A total of 120 observations were collated from 16 studies conducted over the last two decades. While researchers identified 17 different types of individual restoration benefits in the literature, including enhanced initial ecosystem services and avoided wildfire costs (AWC), many more benefits exist that have yet to be quantified.
Key findings and recommendations:
For every dollar invested in forest restoration in high risk, high-value forested watersheds where all quantified benefits are present, over seven dollars of benefit may be returned to investors.
Applying a financial type of return-on-investment to forest restoration, where only returns in excess (or below) of the initial investment are calculated, indicates the potential for a 600% return on investments in the most valuable at-risk forested watersheds.
Many other unique restoration benefits exist that have not been economically quantified and were not included in the meta-analysis, which indicates that the total returns on investments in forest restoration are likely greater than presented in this study.
This approach may also be used to develop an economic measure for the value of a restored acre, which includes improved ecological conditions and wildfire resilience.
Collaboratives & Treatment Prioritization
The early 2000s signaled the start of an increase in cross-jurisdictional and cross-organizational cooperation, collaboration, and partnership through programs like the New Mexico CFRP, federal CFLRP, and integration of nonprofit flexibility into agency objectives. The 2020 New Mexico Forest Action Plan builds off this collaborative foundation by clearly stating the need for collective action to guide and meet the forest and watershed health and restoration goals laid out for 2020-2030. The strategy specifies that the work of the NM Forestry Division’s collaborative partners is closely integrated and important to achieving success. There are many forms that partnerships can take, but one of the most impactful is Landscape Collaboratives, like the Zuni Mountains Collaborative or the 2-3-2 Partnership, that bring together many individuals and organizations over a large geographic area to identify and work toward shared land management goals across multiple specialties and land ownerships.
The New Mexico Forest Action Plan (FAP) identifies multiple strategies to address the challenges facing our State’s forests, water, wildlife, and communities, but the first (Restore Forests and Watersheds) addresses what is arguably the most expensive issue facing forest management today— the legacy of fire exclusion and current land conditions. “In the absence of naturally occurring wildfires, forests have generated excessive fuels which has, in the past two decades, resulted in catastrophic wildfires burning much hotter than previously experienced. These ‘mega-fires’ are happening every year around the West and threaten water supply, lives and property. Experience has demonstrated that forest management treatments such as thinning, burning, and especially a combination of thinning and burning, can moderate fire behavior.” The strategy outlines a plan and identifies collaborative opportunities for addressing these fuel conditions and restoring forest stand densities to healthier conditions at large scale and across ownership boundaries to maximize ecosystem services and resilience to climate change and other identified threats.
Some of the strategies within the FAP that integrate collaboration:
Conduct appropriate treatments in collaboratively identified large-scale priority areas;
Conduct collaborative planning and build collective capacity to increase the pace and scale of forest and watershed restoration;
Develop collaborative strategies to promote a dynamic patchwork mosaic of riparian and wetland vegetation and habitat;
Support and expand public outreach and education to foster a society that supports watershed restoration activities and values resilient and healthy forest ecosystems.
If we want to increase the “pace and scale” of forest and watershed restoration in the state, we need to streamline the flow of putting money on the ground and add administrative capacity. We also need to ensure that all of our priorities match - state and federal agencies have put a lot of time, thought, and effort into planning like the strategies mentioned above, and there is a lot of room for alignment across collaborators. Mechanisms to make those partnerships official, like Good Neighbor Agreements, provide local entities a seat at the table when it comes to planning and implementing projects that improve ecological resilience, promote rural economic development, and improve community health and safety. Collaboratively written documents like Community Wildfire Protection Plans (CWPPs) can meld and incorporate the priorities of communities and natural resource professionals into one document that clearly outlines actional next steps.
Once a project area is identified, all members of the collaborative can decide what “tools” from the “toolbox” are best suited to get work done on the ground to improve resources while accomplishing other priority goals. The collaborative can also agree on which funding source(s) are easiest for accomplishing that work.
Key takeaways:
Good planning means aligning federal, state, local, and hyperlocal priorities.
With solid plans in place, collaborative groups can move beyond relationship building and into detailed project development and implementation.
Streamlining the flow of funding and adding local government capacity may prove to be the key to achieving “pace and scale” at the landscape level.
To dive into a local example of collaborative partnership at work, view this presentation from Taos County and read about the work they have accomplished since then.
Additional Resources
Funding opportunities
State Farm® and the National Volunteer Fire Council (NVFC) are proud to team up for the Good Neighbor Firefighter Safety Program to help resource-constrained volunteer fire departments secure needed equipment. The program launched in 2024, and due to overwhelming demand State Farm doubled its initial commitment – awarding $1 million in grants to 100 departments. View the 2024 grant infographic.
In 2025, the commitment grows even further. State Farm will award a total of $1.5 million to 150 volunteer fire departments. Each will receive a $10,000 grant to help them secure essential equipment that will improve firefighter safety, effectiveness, and efficiency and enable them to better serve their communities.
The funder is holding office hours on Thursday, May 15 | 12:00 – 12:30 p.m. ET and Thursday, May 29 | 7:00 – 7:30 p.m. ET to answer questions and share additional information. Applications open on June 4 and close on June 6. To learn more and register, visit www.nvfc.org/good-neighbor-firefighter-safety-program/
In-person learning
Post-Fire Lessons Learned Panel Discussion: May 29, 5:30pm (Session 3 of the Enchanted Circle Wildfire Preparedness Series)
UNM Taos Bataan Hall, 121 Civic Plaza Dr., Taos, NM 87571
This series of panel discussions from UNM Taos, Taos County, Kit Carson Electric Coopertive, and Enchanted Circle Association of Realtors is dedicated to wildfire prevention and preparedness in the region. It is designed to equip community members with essential resources and information to enhance preparedness for potential wildfires, continuing on May 29 with a presentation about post-fire lessons learned. Previous topics in the series have included how to protect your home from wildfire and state of the forest.
Webinars
RMRS webinars on Behave7 software: May 20th (best for fire analysts) and May 22nd (best for prescribed fire planners) at 11:00am
These webinars are a two part series of trainings for the Behave Fire Modeling System. These webinars will go over changes in version 7 from the RMRS Fire, Fuel, and Smoke Science Program, as well as a look forward at future releases. Registration is required and the webinars will contain duplicate information since they are aimed at different users. To learn more and to register, visit www.swfireconsortium.org/2025/05/06/the-behave7-fire-modeling-system-is-here/
2025 Tribal Climate Resilience Webinar Series: June 3, July 1, and August 5 at 12:00pm
Throughout 2025, the Southwest Climate Adaptation Science Center is hosting a series of webinars on climate adaptation and resilience for tribal environmental and natural resources professionals. The Center has already hosted webinars in February - May, with three more in the series coming up in June-August. Upcoming topics include creating climate adaptation plans, climate resilience funding, and tribal climate resilience success stories. To learn more, visit www.swcasc.arizona.edu/events/sw-casc-tribal-climate-resilience-webinar-series. To revisit the earlier webinars in this series, visit www.swcasc.arizona.edu/tribes/2025-tribal-climate-resilience-webinar-series